Songshun Steel & TOP Steel Manufacturer Supplier in China

ESR H13 Steel: Precautions for Electroslag Remelting Technology

In modern manufacturing, the ESR process has become an essential method for producing high-quality special steel, serving as the core procedure that determines the final cleanliness, microstructure homogeneity and service performance of H13 steel. Therefore, to achieve superior quality in ESR H13 steel via electro-slag remelting, rigorous control of every detail and precise regulation of all process parameters are required across all stages including electrode preparation, slag system composition, melting rate, solidification process, feeding operation and annealing. This paper systematically elaborates on the key precautions for ESR production of this steel grade one by one.

I. Electrode Preparation Stage


The quality of the base material acts as the primary threshold governing the ESR production. Many practitioners mistakenly believe electro-slag remelting can remedy all defects of raw materials. In reality, inherent flaws in the electrode cannot be fully eliminated by ESR; instead, they will persist in alternative forms after remelting. If the electrode fails to maintain sufficient cleanliness, all subsequent processing efforts will be rendered futile.

1.1 Control of Electrode Surface Quality

Shot blasting or grinding treatment is mandatory to thoroughly remove surface scale, rust and oil contaminants. Surface attachments will infiltrate the slag bath and molten steel during remelting, raising the content of oxide inclusions in liquid steel and even triggering spot-type defects.

No visually detectable cracks, scale, shrinkage cavities or porosity are permitted on the electrode surface. Special attention shall be paid to the riser end of ingot-cast electrodes, which must be completely cut off. Otherwise, slag entrapment and abnormal gas evolution tend to occur in the remelting process.

1.2 Uniformity of Electrode Chemical Composition

The base stock for electrode rods shall undergo EAF/LF/VD refining in advance, and the consumable electrodes must have chemical composition deviations between the head and tail within specification limits. Severe segregation of alloying elements such as C, Cr, Mo and V in ESR H13 steel can be alleviated yet cannot be completely eliminated by ESR; such segregation will ultimately manifest as axial composition fluctuation across the ESR ingot.

Sampling and re-inspection shall be carried out for each individual electrode to prevent overall composition variation of the finished remelted ingot.

Special pre-control measures are required for easily oxidizable elements (Al, Ti and rare earth elements). These elements suffer oxidation loss during electro-slag remelting, so an allowance for burn-off must be reserved in the initial electrode composition; otherwise, the chemical composition of final products may fall below the lower specification limit.

1.3 Significance of Vacuum Degassing

Sufficient vacuum degassing shall be implemented during the smelting of electrode base stock to minimize gaseous contents including hydrogen, oxygen and nitrogen in the steel. Excess dissolved gases are the primary cause of internal defects in ESR ingots, such as flakes and blowholes.

1.4 Indispensable Electrode Preheating

Consumable electrodes shall be fully preheated to 400–500 °C prior to service. Preheated electrodes can rapidly raise the melting rate once immersed into the slag bath and prevent cracking or spalling of the electrode.

II. Slag System Selection and Slag Material Preparation


During the electroslag remelting of H13 steel, the slag system performs multiple functions: electrode melting, heat storage and thermal insulation, molten steel refining, and solidification & crystallization, laying the foundation for stable remelting production. Analogous to a “filter” for molten steel, an improperly selected slag system will prevent the production of high-quality steel even with high-precision equipment.

2.1 Matching Principles of Basic Slag System

A quaternary slag system of CaF₂-CaO-Al₂O₃-MgO is generally recommended for AISI H13 steel. This slag system features excellent electrical conductivity, favorable fluidity, and superior capabilities for deoxidation and inclusion modification.

Special attention must be paid to controlling the proportion of Al₂O₃; excessive alumina will push the aluminum content in steel above specification limits and impair the impact toughness of H13. In addition, the total content of unstable oxides such as FeO, MnO and SiO₂ in slag materials shall be strictly restricted.

2.2 Complete Baking of Slag Materials

All slag materials must be baked at 400–800 °C for no less than 4 hours prior to use. This step is critical to prevent hydrogen-induced cracking (HIC). Even trace moisture retained in the slag will lead to non-compliance in the non-destructive testing (NDT) of ESR H13 steel.

After baking, the slag shall be kept warm inside the furnace. Once the ESR furnace is ready for operation, power shall be supplied immediately for slag melting to minimize air exposure and avoid reabsorption of moisture.

2.3 Precise Control of Slag Dosage

The slag layer thickness is normally maintained at 8%–12% of the crystallizer diameter. An overly thin slag layer causes severe temperature fluctuations and weakens the refining effect; an excessively thick slag layer raises power consumption and readily forms a deep molten metal pool.

The required slag mass shall be accurately calculated according to the crystallizer dimensions before production. Estimation based solely on experience is strictly prohibited.

III. Slag Melting and Arc Initiation Stage


This stage is a quality-sensitive period most likely to be overlooked. Although slag melting accounts for only 10% of the total ESR process duration, it determines whether the subsequent remelting of ESR H13 steel can proceed stably.

3.1 Control of Slag Melting Duration

The total slag feeding time is recommended to be controlled within 40 minutes, and the overall slag melting time shall not exceed 75 minutes. Excessively prolonged slag melting exposes the electrode tip to a high-temperature oxidizing atmosphere for an extended period, aggravating oxidation and reducing the cleanliness of the initial molten steel. When initiating an arc directly with the consumable electrode, the arc starter material must be clean and dry to prevent the introduction of foreign impurities.

3.2 Quality Control at the Arc Initiation End

The arc initiation end of an ESR ingot is the section most prone to blowholes and slag inclusions. The surface of the bottom water tank must be kept clean, dry, free of rust and residual water. A relatively thick slag layer shall be maintained in the early arc striking phase to fully isolate air. The melting rate should be appropriately reduced during arc initiation to facilitate stable formation of the molten pool.

IV. Stable Remelting Stage


This stage accounts for over 80% of the total electroslag remelting duration. Three core factors — melting rate, electrical parameters and protective atmosphere — jointly determine the internal quality of the steel ingot.

4.1 Melting Rate Control

The melting rate directly governs molten pool depth and dendrite arm spacing. An excessively high melting rate for ESR H13 steel deepens the molten pool, promotes well-developed columnar grains, aggravates center segregation, elevates shrinkage cavity risks, and degrades transverse impact toughness. Conversely, an overly low melting rate leads to low production efficiency, high power consumption, ultra-fine dendrites, and accelerated precipitation & coarsening of carbides.

Fluctuations of the melting rate during remelting shall be controlled within ±5%; drastic power upregulation or downregulation is strictly forbidden. Only a steady melting rate can yield a uniform solidification microstructure.

4.2 Precision Regulation of Electrical Parameters

A dual closed-loop control scheme combining voltage swing control and melting rate control delivers superior remelting stability compared with single current control alone. Attention shall be paid to disturbances from grid voltage fluctuations; high-power ESR furnaces are recommended to be equipped with voltage stabilizers.

4.3 Protective Atmosphere & Gas Pickup Control

Argon shielding gas must be continuously supplied throughout remelting. Without atmosphere protection, open-type ESR furnaces will enable molten steel to absorb nitrogen and hydrogen from ambient air, raising the risk of aging cracking in finished products.

Compared with conventional atmospheric ESR, Protective Electroslag Remelting (PESR) reduces nitrogen content in steel by more than 30% and achieves lower total oxygen content. This is the primary reason PESR is widely adopted for premium-grade H13 die steel.

V. Solidification and Forming


Purified molten steel forms a molten pool at the bottom of the water-cooled copper mold and undergoes directional solidification from bottom to top and from the outer layer inward, producing dense ESR ingots. This stage realizes the reconstruction and optimization of the internal microstructure of steel.

5.1 Precision Regulation of Solidification Rate

Solidification rate exerts a remarkable influence on grain size and segregation severity. An excessively fast solidification rate may trigger stress concentration, while an overly slow rate leads to coarse grains. Optimizing the solidification rate by adjusting current, voltage and cooling intensity is the key to acquiring uniform microstructures.

5.2 Crystallizer Cooling System

ESR H13 steel is sensitive to thermal stress during solidification. The cooling procedure must be strictly controlled to prevent solidification cracking.

Increasing circulating water pressure accelerates the cooling rate of molten steel, lowers the precipitation temperature of carbides and slows their coarsening, which refines carbide particles and mitigates segregation.

Strict control over cooling water temperature and cooling intensity is required. Excessively high water temperature results in insufficient cooling capacity, readily causing surface defects such as rippled skin and slag grooves on ingots. In contrast, excessively low water temperature delivers over-intense cooling and an overly thick chill layer, which hinders the floating and removal of inclusions.

The pressure, flow rate, temperature and flow distribution of cooling water shall remain stable without abrupt fluctuations. The inner surface condition, assembly precision and sealing performance of the crystallizer must also be maintained in good condition.

4.3 Protective Atmosphere & Gas Pickup Control

Argon shielding gas must be continuously supplied throughout remelting. Without atmosphere protection, open-type ESR furnaces will enable molten steel to absorb nitrogen and hydrogen from ambient air, raising the risk of aging cracking in finished products.

Compared with conventional atmospheric ESR, Protective Electroslag Remelting (PESR) reduces nitrogen content in steel by more than 30% and achieves lower total oxygen content. This is the primary reason PESR is widely adopted for premium-grade H13 die steel.

VI. Feeding and Hot Topping


This stage is the final procedure determining ingot yield, which eliminates shrinkage cavities and porosity at the ingot top and directly governs the compactness of the upper section of ESR ingots.

6.1 Timely Feeding Operation

Power must be gradually reduced to implement slow feeding within the last 30 minutes before melting completion. If this step is omitted, massive shrinkage cavities will form at the head of H13 ingots, resulting in an extremely high cropping loss during subsequent forging and substantial cost waste.

Furthermore, the feeding schedule shall be precisely adjusted according to ingot dimension, melting rate and cooling intensity. By gradually lowering current and melting rate, the residual molten pool at the top shrinks gently to fully eliminate V-type shrinkage pipe and guarantee full densification of the ingot head.

Insufficient feeding tends to trigger shrinkage cavities, porosity or inadequate internal compactness; overfeeding or unstable feeding rhythm will also impair the microstructure of the ingot body.

6.2 Design and Control of Hot Riser

Rational hot riser design paired with precise temperature control can effectively guide shrinkage cavities to migrate upward for subsequent complete removal, thereby ensuring sound compactness of the usable portion of the ingot.

6.3 Stepwise Power Reduction Regime

Direct power cut-off to halt melting is forbidden during feeding. A stepwise power reduction scheme must be adopted to shrink the molten pool volume progressively, allowing molten steel to continuously compensate solidification shrinkage.

VII. Demolding, Cooling and Subsequent Treatment


This stage serves as a critical buffering procedure to prevent cracking. Most cracks occurring in ESR ingots stem from improper demolding and annealing processes rather than defects in the remelting process itself.

7.1 Demolding Aging

Immediate demolding is prohibited upon the completion of feeding. The ingot shall be held static for 30 to 60 minutes until the surface layer solidifies and acquires sufficient strength for ingot stripping. Early demolding tends to cause deformation and even surface cracks due to insufficient high-temperature strength of the ingot. By contrast, excessive demolding delay will lead the cooled and contracted ingot to tightly grip the crystallizer, resulting in difficult demolding and surface scratching.

7.2 Uniform Retarded Cooling

Uniform cooling must be maintained throughout the entire cooling process. Non-uniform cooling is the primary cause of flakes and cracks. The prolonged stress-relieving retarded cooling process is designed to eliminate casting stress and avoid internal stress concentration and cracking induced by rapid cooling.

7.3 Timely Annealing

ASTM H13 steel is a high-alloy tool steel with high thermal stress and structural stress. The ingots must be immediately transferred to the annealing furnace after demolding, and natural cooling to low temperature is strictly forbidden.

7.4 Quality Inspection

Strict ultrasonic non-destructive testing shall be implemented to inspect surface defects such as overlaps, slag inclusions and cracks. All surface defects require intensive grinding to ensure the quality of subsequent forging and rolling processes.

VIII. FAQs on Key Precautions for ESR H13 Steel


Q: Can ESR remelting completely eliminate segregation and inclusions in H13 steel?

A: Complete elimination cannot be achieved; however, ESR can significantly mitigate segregation and improve steel cleanliness. The core lies in shallow molten pool control and appropriate cooling intensity, which confines segregation within the allowable specification range. The refining effect is determined by the electrode quality, slag composition, and the accuracy of process control.

Q: Is deoxidation control necessary during ESR H13 steel?

A: Yes, strict deoxidation control is essential. H13 die steel requires extremely high cleanliness. Excessive oxygen, hydrogen and nitrogen introduced from raw materials, slag materials and the remelting environment will substantially increase the risks of porosity, inclusions and material brittleness.

Q: Why is strict hydrogen control mandatory for ESR H13 material?

A: Hydrogen is the dominant element causing flaks (hairline cracks) and hydrogen embrittlement in steel, which poses severe hazards especially for large forgings. Reducing the hydrogen content below 2 ppm via VD vacuum degassing, combined with hydrogen absorption prevention measures of the slag system, can effectively avoid hydrogen-induced defects.

IX. Conclusion


The electroslag remelting process for ESR H13 steel is an integrated system requiring precise coordination across every stage—from electrode preparation and feeding/cooling to final quality inspection. Each step involves critical technical parameters that must be strictly adhered to; any lapse in control at any stage will ultimately compromise the steel’s service life. Therefore, at Songshun, we exercise rigorous control over every aspect of the ESR H13 electroslag remelting process, dedicated to producing steel of the highest quality.

Songshun Steel-Logo

Dongguan Songshun Mould Steel Co., Ltd.

Welcome to contact us at any time through the following ways
Or you can email directly to  sales@songshunsteel.com